« Speed problems and slow performanceFault resolution and Migration of ISP to BT »

How anti-virus suggestions are formed


How anti-virus suggestions are formed

Permalink 03:44:00 pm by Eugene Gardner, Categories: Security, Anti-Virus

Each year I review the comparative group tests of the major labs to glean the consensus of the ?best? security product. That is the one I buy many licenses of at wholesale prices and recommend to anyone who?ll listen.

The labs I generally look at are

No one lab will give the definitive best product as they

  • test different products - there are scores of anti-virus products available so each lab can only test a sub-set
  • use different test environments - some test with viruses captured ?in the wild? while others roll their own bespoke test suites; some test on multiple platforms others just one version of Windows
  • report results differently - some score 1-5 stars, others use 3 or more groups of words, others just award a pass/fail; so comparing one set of results with another is not straight forward
  • record different capabilities - examples of capabilities that are measured are detection, prevention, cleanup, usability, cost, false positives, extra features, and performance
  • test different catagories of malware - all will test trojans and worms but not all test keyloggers, screengrabbers, zero-day exploits?

So I look at all and form my own opinion based on the consensus. Although all the labs are independent, some are commissioned to conduct tests by one of the anti-virus companies and those companies usually get a good score. This is not because of anything underhand but shows that the issues found have been corrected. As long as the reader is aware of this it is not a problem as the other products are tested on a level playing field.

I read through many reports and assess the value of the most recent evaluations. I then form an almost subjective opinion based on objective criteria.

Trackback address for this post

Trackback URL (right click and copy shortcut/link location)

No feedback yet

Click here to return to the 1ComputerCare home page.

This is designed to supersede the newsletters that I just don't have time to produce to the standard I would want any more. Please register so that you may read and leave comments and subscribe to have posts automatically e-mailed to you.

Comments and suggestions are always welcome.

User tools


November 2023
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
 << <   > >>
    1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30      


XML Feeds

CMS engine